MisleadingCharts
Back to the gallery

The 241,158-acre record drawn as tall as Alaska’s 5.1 million

Showing the misleading chart

Be the first to star this exhibit

A crew bulletin we drew shows eleven years of wildfire acres for each of the ten US geographic areas, one panel per area, each scaled to its own peak. Only the Eastern Area’s line finishes on the top edge of its panel, so the headline says the fire map is tilting east. But the East’s top edge stands for 241,158 acres and Alaska’s for 5,111,404: the East’s record reaches the same height as a season 21 times its size.

01The claim

Across the ten geographic areas, only the East finished 2025 at its high, and its line now climbs the way the big western lines did: the fire map is tilting east.

02The trick

Each panel’s y-axis runs from zero to that area’s own eleven-year peak, so every panel’s highest year touches the same top edge. That turns the top edge into a different number in every panel: 241,158 acres for the Eastern Area, 5,111,404 for Alaska, and between 1,021,951 and 2,779,003 for the other eight. The East’s record therefore reaches exactly the height of Alaska’s 2015 season, 21 times its size, and of the Northwest’s 2,074,585 in 2024, 8.6 times its size. The bulletin’s figures are all right. The Eastern Area burned 241,158 acres in 2025, after 64,342, 113,416 and 206,667 in the three years before, which is 2.6 times its 2015–2024 average of 92,976. It is the only area that finished 2025 at its 11-year high, and the only one with three straight years of increases in the table. What the scaling hides is size. The headline compares the East’s climb with the West’s, and in this grid a line’s height only shows how close a year came to that area’s own worst. (We drew this bulletin ourselves as a demonstration; the acres are NICC’s.)

03The fix

The redraw puts all ten panels on one axis, 0 to 6 million acres. Alaska’s 2015 season towers over the grid. Northern California’s 2020 reaches 2.8 million, and the Great Basin, the Northwest and the Southern Area each top 2 million in their worst years. The Eastern Area is a flat orange line along the floor: all eleven of its years add up to 1,170,915 acres, fewer than the Southern Area burned in 2024 alone (1,994,830). In 2025 the East had 19.7% of the nation’s 77,850 wildfires but 4.7% of its 5,131,474 acres, about 16 acres a fire against 2,164 in Alaska. The bulletin also had a fair point that the one-axis chart cannot show: was 2025 unusual for each area? A second chart answers that, dividing each area’s 2025 acres by its own 2015–2024 average. There the East does lead, at 2.59 times its normal, ahead of the Rocky Mountain area at 1.16 and Southern California at 1.04, with Northern California at 0.10. Unusual for the East, small for the country. Each question gets its own chart, and each chart says which question it answers.