MisleadingCharts
Back to the gallery

The zigzag that put your workout in the same league as your stairs

Showing the misleading chart

Be the first to star this exhibit

A physical therapy newsletter (one we drew ourselves) charts 2024’s emergency-room injuries by the product involved, from the CPSC’s NEISS sample, and finds exercise up among beds, sofas and stairs. Every bar starts at zero and every value is printed. But a zigzag deletes the axis from 1.3 million to 2.95 million, so stairs and floors (3,101,789) are drawn 2.9 times as tall as exercise (564,845) instead of 5.5. For patients 65 and older the gap is 11.8 to 1.

01The claim

Exercise sends Americans to the emergency room on the same scale as the house itself: in 2024 it was involved in 564,845 ER visits, the most of any sports or recreation group, and its column stands in the same range as beds, sofas and stairs. So book a movement screen before you step up your training.

02The trick

The bars start at zero, every value is printed, and every number is the CPSC’s. Exercise has the largest estimate in the table’s sports and recreation section, ahead of bicycles (454,008), basketball (385,777) and football (318,243), though these are sample estimates and the top two overlap within their margins of error. The distortion is a zigzag across the y-axis. The axis runs from 0 to 1.3 million, skips to 2.95 million and resumes, so the only bar that crosses the gap, stairs, ramps, landings and floors at 3,101,789, has 1.65 million injuries cut out of its middle. That is more scale than the entire lower axis (1.3 million). The two halves aren’t even drawn at the same rate: above the zigzag, 100,000 visits get almost as much height as 200,000 below it. The stairs column comes out 2.9 times as tall as the exercise column when it should be 5.5 times as tall, and 1.5 times as tall as beds (1,114,811) when it should be 2.8. A bar encodes its value by its length, so once a slice of the axis is removed, the lengths stop being proportional to anything. The printed 3,101,789 is correct, but the column drawn above it is not. In this chart the deleted stretch is exactly the part that separates stairs from everything else. (We drew this newsletter ourselves as a demonstration; the estimates are CPSC’s.)

03The fix

The redraw puts all seven groups on one continuous axis from 0 to 3.5 million. Stairs and floors now tower over the chart: 3,101,789 ER visits, about 2.5 million more than exercise and almost three times beds, the next group. Exercise sits in a cluster of mid-sized bars with bathroom fixtures, bicycles and basketball. A second panel, on its own zero-based axis and labelled as such, shows the same groups for patients 65 and older. Here stairs and floors were involved in 1,400,627 visits, 45% of their all-ages total, against 119,127 for exercise: 11.8 to 1. Basketball nearly disappears at 2,402. Exercise injuries are real, and a sports clinic is right to talk about them; the honest chart simply shows them at their true size next to the household groups the newsletter compared them with. The newsletter also chose its seven groups: clothing (465,513) and ceilings and walls (406,621) are larger than bicycles and basketball but aren’t shown. Two caveats apply to both charts. NEISS figures are estimates from a sample of hospitals, with coefficients of variation of .08 to .12 for these groups. They also record the products involved in an injury, not its cause, and one injury can count under up to three products.